I wasn’t trying to be green…I was just living out my faith.

By Holly

The “green” movement still bemuses me. It’s a bandwagon that shouldn’t have been jumped on “en masse” by Christians, simply because Al Gore and Brian McLaren and various Hollywood stars manufactured the issue of the decade. Rather, it should have been a way of life for God’s people, from Adam forward. Stewardship is an injunction consistent with Christianity.

We should conserve, because it pleases God, not because Sheryl Crow makes a music video guilting us into using 2 sheets of toilet paper.  Sheryl’s show has the opposite effect.  It makes me want to fling toilet paper into the potty like an unsupervised two year old.  (Don’t worry.  I don’t.  I’m too frugal.)

As God’s people, we should be frugal when it comes to wasting resources. When it comes to love and care and nurture, we should be extravagent. We should set the course, be the example, for the rest of the world. We should do this without legislation, without being forced. (It is interesting to me that often it is those who most loudly proclaim that the government should not legislate what people do in their bedrooms are those who want the government to jump in and give us all sorts of laws and regulations about the environment. “Because it’s really important” is their explanation – as if morality is not.)

For me, I’ve always been what I would call “crunchy.” I’m not willing to be called “green,” because of the associations. I advocate stewardship, loving care and conservation – NOT the elevation of the rare tree frog above the American infant in the womb. (And truly, the rare animal/insect/amphibian species is more protected than a pre-born human infant. It is recently cool in Christianity to clean up a marsh for a yellow-striped swamp turtle but NOT COOL to work at a crisis pregnancy center. Abortion is SO yesterday in our radar.)

I was raised crunchy, although we didn’t know it. We just thought we were doing what good stewards did. My husband and children and I are still crunchy – although we thought we were just being frugal. The two go hand in hand, you know. Most often, IF NOT LEGISLATED, the most “green” choice is also the cheapest.

Some examples:

  • We do not use chemicals on our lawn. We like dandelions. We also don’t water our lawn. If there’s a lack of rainfall, we have a brown lawn. So be it.
  • Cloth napkins. We couldn’t stand to throw away paper napkins, meal after meal, day after day. We added up the cost, and couldn’t believe how much money we were literally throwing away. Cloth napkins work better, don’t fall apart on messy spaghetti faces.
  • Turn off lights, turn the heat down at night. Saves money, saves resources. I just don’t want the government dictating to me what lightbulb I must use. “Free country,” my eye.
  • Shop second hand, when possible. Less fossil fuels used to produce new items, less waste going to landfills.
  • Garden, when possible. We thought everyone did this. How else do people feed their families? How do they entertain their children in the summer? Organic gardening…just for the cost of the sweat of the brow. It doesn’t get better than that.
  • “Eating local” is the newest phrase. Again, we just thought everyone did this. It makes sense. If you garden, eating local is a no-brainer. You can’t get more local than your back yard.
  • We require short showers, because we’ve felt the pinch of high water bills. We’ve got 3 children in the range of teen-hood, and simply can’t afford for each to have 20 minute spa sessions in the shower each morning. We ask them to turn on the water to get wet, then turn it off. They lather up, then turn the water back on to rinse. Once again, frugality equals convervation which equals stewardship.
  • There are many more ways we live out our faith in manners consistent with Christian stewardship, but this gets you started…

In many ways, we have been naive to think that because we lived this way the rest of the Christian world lived in like manner. We recently spent a weekend with a young family with two small children. (They do not read the blog, and even upon torture I will not divulge their names.) They were a young, two career family on the fast track to even better careers with money to burn and both children in full-time day care. It was eye-opening to visually verify that a family of ten who are fiscally conservative can live more environmentally frugal than a family of four. Non-sustainable products flew into the trash with regularity. Water poured from the faucets like there was no limit. Excess ruled. Neither stewardship nor frugality were considered. These things take time, and they were short on time. (This is an assessment, not a judgement. They are beautiful people and we love them. It was just surprising, and caused us to see that not all Christians choose stewardship.) Because of stewardship, which is a biblical concept, our family of ten is able to live on less income AND spend more time together AND carry less debt than a family of four with differing priorities.  So much for the old “you shouldn’t have a large family because they consume too many resources” argument.  Well-raised children will grow up to be good stewards, and they will produce much more than they will consume.  They will return more to the earth than they take.

Living a life of stewardship is consistent with Christianity.  It is consistent with a good, rewarding and satisfying life.  God initiated it, way back in the beginning, and we would do well to live out our faith in like manner.

34 Responses to “I wasn’t trying to be green…I was just living out my faith.”

  1. Shannon M Says:

    Amen! I can’t tell you how many times I’ve had moms and dads of one or two comment on our family size because “the earth is running out of resources for the people that are already here” as they throw away paper plates, run the dishwasher for a few dishes, gas up their SUVs (why does one need an Suv that seats 8 when one has a family of 4?), or pops birthcontrol pills that are mutating our fish supply. Being an environmentalist is showy, where as being a good steward is not. My sister at a Christian college knows kids who are flying and then driving to clean up a marsh somewhere. Never mind the fossil fuel they’re burning up. But nobody thinks it’s cool to wash out ziploc baggies:)

  2. Heather Says:

    I agree 100%. It amazes me what people will do and spend to buy something “green” while going through the drive thru and driving fifty miles to buy it. (I recently read of someone who was all about some little lastic clips for using as book marks instead of the toss away paper tabs for his college books because it was “green”. Um , before those little paper tabs we used paper clips or scraps of no longer needed paper (recycling) and being a college student and judging from what he writes on his blog I am betting that he throws away more carryout packaging than he will ever use as little paper tabs. People are silly.

    I don’t consider us green or crunchy but I suspect that we, by being frugal with what God has given us, eating mostly fresh veggies and things with little packaging, and only shopping second hand, by having only one car and staying home as often as possible, are better stewards than some of the “green” people I know. (I end up on a lot of vegetarian blogs because we don’t eat much meat–too expensive and I am always watching for recipes for preservative free meals due to Rachel’s food allergies–it is amazing what people do and say.)

    It certainly isn’t something to be proud of or some band wagon to jump on. People have been doing it for years–my grandma STILL keeps old bread bags and washes off aluminum foil. We reuse sandwich bags and carry canvas shopping bags and refuse to get the newspaper (I can read online–why on earth do I want MORE papers strewn about the house.)

    Anyway, people are silly. And those who think that making laws to MAKE people behave are silly. (ANd I am very angry about the fluorescent light thing–RAchel can’t use them because of her seizures. HATES IT!)

    Oh, and I should mention that I have moved blogs. :) Long story but there it is.

  3. Holly Says:

    Thank you Heather, I haven’t been able to get out into the blogosphere much. It’s been nuts here! :)

    And something else…I wouldn’t have even known to call us crunchy until the last year. It’s not something we plan to do or become or adopt…it probably just most closely describes how we live by default.

  4. I think I’m getting crunchy…. « Undivided Heart Says:

    [...] 19, 2008 by Michelle Holly has a really great post about conservation, being Christian and crunchy, but not green. It echos so much of what has been swimming around in my mind and heart lately. [...]

  5. Holly Says:

    Wait. Does crunchy indicate that I need to wear Birkenstocks? Maybe I should re-think my terms!

  6. Jenna Says:

    Crunchy? Green? DH just says, “Jenn, you’re turning into your grandma.” *laughs* I’ve washed my fair share of plastic bags. DH laughs at me about the way that I collect plastic and foam “disposable” dishes and reuse them. For all of that though, I wouldn’t think to call myself “green”. I actually have a pretty negative reaction to even just the word anymore. My mom was deeply involved in an environmentalist group when I was a child. We were always learning about water testing and traipsing through woods and creeks to pick up garbage. These things are important to me. However, I can’t stand how enviro-fanatics want to trample on my freedom because they think they know what is better for me, and everyone else. I’m all for being a good steward, but not for elevating this earth as a god to be worshiped. I have actually heard it said that it would be favorable if a HUGE percentage of our human population died off, because there are too many people to be beneficial for the earth (resources, CO2). Goodness.

  7. Holly Says:

    Ah! See, Jenna? Most of our Grandmothers lived that way. It’s just something that they did. Things were not easy to come by, and they had to take care of what they had. We would do well to become like our grandparents…to a degree! :)

  8. Smockity Frocks Says:

    Well said, Holly!

  9. Michelle Says:

    Hooooollllllyyyyy…..I think that is the whole point of your post! If you have to go out and buy special shoes to be “crunchy” or a good steward or conservation minded, then you’re NOT being conservation minded!! (Besides, I don’t care for them all that much, so please don’t tell me I have to go buy special, expensive shoes!! ;o)

  10. Holly Says:

    I was just teasing, Michelle. I was sitting around, eating bon bons this a.m., when I thought…maybe this means we are hippies! Just being silly!

  11. Tiffany Says:

    Fantastic post holly. Agree so much! Although I do love my birkenstocks. ;) Don’t worry about those though, I think Crocs are the new green shoe. :)

    On a serious note- many of the “green” groups stuff I am certainly on board for. However, like you, I have serious qualms about legislating it. And further more, I am deeply saddened and disturbed how wide spread the ideas of reproductive and sexual rights are in political groups that hold green principles. Of course not everyone who wants environmental legislation passed also wants abortion legislation passed, but two do seem to go together frequently.

    Of course many green Christians would then say that this is Christianity’s fault. That if we had been leading the way in the green group it would be different. But I really don’t think that is an accurate assessment. Rather, I think it is a millennial old problem of elevating the created above the creator. Worship of the earth is almost as old as the earth itself, and so much of the environmental groups position really do boil down to that- not a living in balance and harmony with the planet, but “protecting” the planet at all costs.

  12. Holly Says:

    Birkenstocks are fine, Tiff! Still just teasing! :) So are Crocs.

    When you follow most of the groups to their core beliefs, Christian or no, they can not, will not say that they believe it could possibly be good for the planet for families to have many children. (Sometimes “many” is defined as more than one.) When is comes down to it, humans are always the problem. I disagree! God gives humans such incredible creativity and imaginative ways to solve problems. What I see is this: Many Christian enviro groups remove all thought of God’s hand in planetary life. They subscribe to a doomsday outlook; giving man WAY too much importance in the health of the planet. When this earth ends (And I know some of my readers would say “if,) will it be because humans killed it? Or will it be because the fullness of time has come and Christ returns?

    Having said all of that…I can concur with who ever says that Christians have not always cared for the earth as they should. I think we should have all been living much less consumeristic, materialistic, more simplistic lives. I’m also saying that many of the generations before us DID live like that…and many still try to. We just don’t call it “GREEN,” nor do we trumpet it. We just live it.

    I see some WONDERFUL trends amongst Christians. I am glad that they are loving God’s creation, feeling called back to living responsibly, caring for it. Many of the small farms are in the care of those who are called back to the earth, who love the dirt God has given and who spend their lives tending it. I see many urban Christians who are trying to do their part, living conscientiously, purchasing sustainable things, putting their money into things that will last and not be thrown away. I suggest, though, that they do it because it pleases the ONE who created this earth, and not Al, Sheryl, or anyone else. :) Okay, I just say it. I don’t suggest it. :)

    Don’t know if any of this has made sense. Baby is fussing on my lap. Gotta run.

  13. Sheila Says:

    Great post, and great thoughts following.
    Don’t even get me started on high taxes… It’s plain and simple: We don’t know how to think and do for ourselves. We need all the liberals to tell us how to live, spend our money, how many kids to have, etc. HUGHUH! (That was an upchucking sound.)
    Maybe stewardship shoul be preached from the pulpit more often…

  14. Michelle Says:

    I know you were teasing, Holly. Are there enough bon bons left to go around?

  15. sara Says:

    I agree. and my gut tells me that stewardship is Christian principle. But because I’d really like to know, and not because I disagree in any way, how is it a biblical concept? Do you mean when God charged Adam and Eve with the care of the Garden and then, to toil in the field? Seriously, if you have the time, I’m interested. Thanks!

  16. Leigh Ann Says:

    Wonderful thoughts, as always.

  17. Didi Says:

    Very well written and succinct position, Holly. **nodding my head**

    I think of my in-laws and grandparents who live(d) “green” without even knowing it. My in-laws are immigrants who lived in Europe during WWII. They went hungry and had very little. Now, no food is ever wasted, everything is recycled and composted. Resources are always respected.

    It seems people who think of themselves as “green” also have lots of resources. Being green is more of a challenge when it’s not a necessity. It requires discipline and self-control.

    Don’t you love all these terms…crunchy, green? I think I’m soggy. :)

  18. learningpatience Says:

    Great post, Holly. I especially love the bit about how a ten person family can use less and spend more time together. We are only six, but I get the questions “How do you do it?” from neighbors who are two career, and I don’t have a good succinct answer – how can I say in 30 seconds or less (and nicely) that we simply live differently, and it’s in all the details.

    Also, I have been dying to go to cloth napkins, but I have a couple questions. What kind of napkins do you use – are they all cotton? And how do you keep them clean?

    Blessings,
    jen

  19. Holly Says:

    Sara, sorry for the delay! Busy weekend!

    I would say that yes, the mandate issues from God speaking to Adam in the garden. He was given a caretaker’s status, which from what I understand has not been revoked.

    That probably is the most clear evidence, but the entirety of scripture supports man (in God’s image) as steward. The parables are full of farmers, and the wise man who stewards either his garden, his flock, his man servant, his maid servant, his money. Our God is described as a shepherd, likened to a mother hen. There is a side of God that is nurturing, providing, protecting. (There is the side that is King, and warrior and judge, too…) I don’t believe it is too much of a stretch to say that we should emulate Him in this way. It’s just all over the scriptures.

    And hey, it’s okay to not agree with me! That’s not required! Did you have a differing viewpoint, or have you learned something different?

  20. Holly Says:

    Jen,

    I just made some quick ones out of flannel a few years ago. Nothing fancy. It was just a time of real thrift – trying to cut corners any way we could. I found that throwing a few napkins into the laundry was NO BIG DEAL! They surely don’t take up much volume – and they are laundry that the little boys can fold and feel so big while doing so!

    Now, and I’m not really proud to admit this…but when we are just “family” and not company at home, I just use cheapo washcloths that I bought specifically for the purpose. White is a great color, because you can bleach them easily. They clean up messy faces well, too. I understand that’s not fancy…but sometimes you just go with what works! :) I tend to use paper napkins for company.

  21. Holly Says:

    Sara,

    I also was thinking, we are stewards of our children, and our homes…our things….why not our land?

    If God created such a gorgeous place for us to live, wouldn’t it seem to shake our fist in his face to not take care of it?

    Thanks for asking…it makes me think even deeper to explain myself. That’s always good. :)

  22. sara Says:

    Nah, same viewpoint but wasn’t quite sure how to back it up with Scripture. You’ve written in the past about not making an idol of these causes (I’m paraphrasing here) so this post gives a good balance I think.

    thanks for taking the time to answer! I don’t know how you do it.

  23. pauseforamoment Says:

    I like this, Holly. I have to say that we are careful, economical, not wasteful but not ‘religious’ about this. I would say we have a good balance in our home. We enjoy the abundance of the Lord and His blessings, but are stewards of the earth. We recycle what we can, are very, very careful with water (except my husband can NOT shorten his shower time! Aaagh!), only use the drier when it has rained for six days straight, lol, and don’t use throw-away products as a rule.

    I guess some may see some of our other practises as wasteful – like the purchase of new clothing, running the a/c when it is hot, buying imported products, but as I say, we enjoy life but are not wasteful.

    I think that as a nation we have been a lot more ‘green’conscious than America (just from what I read and see – no offence intended to anyone!) for a long time, but Europe leaves us all far behind. I love the way they are so together with recycling etc.

    On the cloth napkins, we use linen, and we each have a unique napkin ring so the same napkin can be used a few times. That way you only have to wash them every three days or so. I imagine with children they would get a lot dirtier, though!

  24. sara Says:

    pauseforamoment, I was curious about the practicalities of cloth napkins – I was thinking of each family member having his own print but I like the idea of unique napkin rings even better!

  25. learningpatience Says:

    Thanks for the napkin tips, Holly & Pauseforamoment!

  26. pauseforamoment Says:

    Pleasure! I like antique silver, and I inherited a couple of these along the way. I always stop into antique stores or second-hand shops to see if they have any – you can pick up a real bargain sometimes!

  27. Holly Says:

    Sara, the thing about blogging is that you can never give your complete and whole opinion in a single post. (At least not easily.) I’ve tried to say the same things before…just hasn’t come out the same. A series of posts would work well, I suppose, but I seem too schizophrenic to ever complete those….

    I also just want to say that I don’t think that anyone should feel burdened to use cloth napkins, or diapers, or whatever. There have been times in my life when they are JUST ONE MORE BURDEN that I couldn’t take on. Each of us has to examine our lives and see what we can and should do, where our energy and time should be going, and weigh the cost. We can’t ALL do it ALL! We can all do some things, though…

    Val, people who really want to scrutinize any of our lives can find where we are wasteful, right? They surely could mine. It sounds like you’ve made some good and wise choices! And you are right about the enjoyment of life, too. I find that quite important!

  28. sara Says:

    :) Well said.

  29. Katy Says:

    I totally agree with this post! Thank you for this post!!! You said everything I was thinking!!!! :)

  30. Smockity Frocks Says:

    Holly, I just finished reading A Midwife’s Story. It is excellent and reminds me of what you are saying. She tells how the Amish take care of the earth because God has given it to them to use for their time here. (If you would like, I can mail you my copy.)

  31. Roberta Says:

    I know I’m a few days behind here Holly, but I agree with what you’re saying. When I saw this website, http://shopwilliamgood.com/Earth.aspx, my jaw dropped to see a repurposed, reconstructed jacket selling for $99. (if you click on the shop button it takes you to their ebay store). Baffling! I wouldn’t pay that for new, why would I pay that for used. Just for a fashion statement, “Hey, I paid way too much for this used clothing!”. I’ve been buying at thriftstores and reconstructing for a handful of years…maybe I shouldn’t complain and figure out how to make a profit at it. :) In all my spare time of course. ;)

  32. Roberta Says:

    whoops, I think I accidently hooked a comma on there. Hopefully this will work.
    http://shopwilliamgood.com/Home.aspx

  33. Zzzz's Says:

    I’m a new reader; found you through Jen at LearningPatience. I didn’t grow up crunchy, and I’ve certainly got a long way to go toward being a better steward. Thanks for sharing your thoughts. It helps me in my learning process. Over time, I know we’ll get there!
    Gratefully,
    Ellen

  34. Random musings waiting to be posted… « Undivided Heart Says:

    [...] a more cheerful note, ever since Holly convinced me to try cloth diapers this time around and her musings on being “crunchy“, I’ve been thinking about other ways to incorporate this philosophy.  Although I [...]

Leave a Reply